The Horror Mystery Box

Looking for spooky awesome Horror merch you won't find anywhere else? From exclusive designs & collectibles, limited edition items, and original characters. Come see why Horror fans think our Horror mystery boxes are the best on the market.

*Packaged in our Halloween Box, Creepmas Box, or regular kraft box with Horror tissue paper  - We've sold out of our Horror box mailers and while the items inside will still be the same, we're now shipping these in different boxes.

Choose Your Box Size

The Horror Bag — $20 (Good Value) - SOLD OUT

4–5 smaller items.
Examples: stickers, pins, standees, coasters, lanyards, notepads & more.
Avg retail value: $30+

The Regular Box — $60 (Great Value)

8–10 items — includes 4-5 smaller items.
May include: beanies, plushies, posters, mugs/tumblers, tote bags & more.
Avg retail value: $90+

The Ultimate Box — $90 (Best Value)

10–12 items — everything in Regular + one BIG item.
BIG item (one): woven throw blanket, 40oz tumbler, or 24oz tumbler + tee*
Shirt size is required, but a shirt is not guaranteed to be inside this box and only applies to the Ultimate box size. 
Avg retail value: $150+

Limited run • No repeats • Curated for true horror fans
🕸️ Spooky Safe Shipping Guarantee — if anything arrives damaged, we replace it.

Over 1000 5-Star reviews for Sterye boxes since 2021

Discover why thousands of customers love our Horror boxes. We do 3-4 different Horror collections a year, and this one would feature items from all of our past collections. Our next Collection is Creepmas and it'll be dropping on 11/27!

Pick your size and unbox a haunting surprise curated for real horror lovers. (Rather our Halloween mystery box? Click Here.) Want a specific item shown in the example boxes to be included? Leave a note at the cart page, or check if we have it available separately from boxes!

Ordered before and back for another? Leave a note at the cart page with items you received in your 1st box and we'll avoid duplicates!